Tree Roots, the Source of Many Tree Issues - Tree Resolutions

March 11, 2014 by Jason C. Miller, RCA, BCMA

Trees growing in the landscape face unique challenges. Often confined or living in inhospitable soils, tree roots can be found at the source of many issues. Below are some examples of tree problems involving roots.

Heavily compacted soil and improper planting cause problems with tree roots.

Landscape diagnostics — A beautiful executive building that has been having tree problems.

No visible root flare — A closer look at the base of one of the subject trees. Note the lack of a discernible root flare.

Fine tree roots — Careful excavation using hand-tools revealed numerous fine roots near the surface.

Where's the flare? — Excavating to 6-8 inches did not reveal the root collar.

Tree roots confined to planting hole — Just outside the mulch, penetrating the soil required significant effort. Using one’s bodyweight provided negligible results (1-2 inch depths).

Poor planting and mulching techniques often shorten the lifespan of trees.

Young maple tree — Nearly all the trees within this development were planted similarly to this maple.

Air-gap around stem indicating movement — A closer look at the base of the maple. Note the lack of root-flare as well as the gap between the mulch and the stem (a textbook symptom of planting too deep).

Fine tree roots circling the stem — Removing the mulch, followed by careful excavation revealed the root-flare was well below grade.

Tree roots positioned to girdle the stem — A closer look showed tree roots that will likely girdle the stem with age.

Heavy clay soil can limit root development in trees, increasing the likelihood of wind-throw.

Uprooted oak tree — This 70 ft. white oak from a neighboring property failed during a thunderstorm (despite partial protection from surrounding trees).

The underside of an uprooted oak showing tree roots — The uprooted stump from the white oak. The roots of this tree were relatively shallow, growing near the surface of clay soil. (In the foreground: Tree crew kind enough to stand-in, providing scale to the-root plate)

Excessive pruning removes a tree’s food-supply, which can lead to underdeveloped roots.

White pines with starving roots — 80-90 ft. tall white pines in this row started to catastrophically fail during seemingly mild wind conditions.

White pines excessively pruned — A distant view of the pines showed signs of excessive pruning in the past, leaving most of their foliage near the tops (not unlike trees in a wooded area).

Uprooted tree stump showing underdeveloped tree roots — A closer look at the stump from one of the uprooted, 80 ft. trees, showing underdeveloped roots (similar to wind-protected trees in a wooded area).

Would you like to learn more? The University of Florida has assembled additional information, photos, and diagrams here: http://hort.ifas.ufl.edu/woody/root-growth-depth1.shtml

Category: Tree CareTag: tree care, Tree Roots

About Jason C. Miller, RCA, BCMA

Jason C. Miller has established a career in the tree care industry spanning over three decades, starting from his humble beginnings as a ground-worker for a small tree service and advancing through various positions such as climber, crew chief, horticulturalist, representative, trainer, and director of a multimillion-dollar tree company. He has completed numerous certificate programs and is a Registered Consulting Arborist and Board-Certified Master Arborist, offering his expertise on a broad spectrum of issues relating to trees and the tree care industry. His proficiency is highly valued by attorneys, insurance professionals, tree company owners, homeowners, and property managers who rely on his competence in resolving intricate disputes and technical issues concerning tree safety, health, value, and the tree care industry.